On June 3, 2019, my boss handed me this:

A formal Performance Improvement Plan. Five categories. Every one of them true.

• Bid to Actual Result Improvement

• Preparedness / Deadlines

• Working with Others — "difficult to work with"

• Teamwork — "many people feel like you are only looking out for your interests"

• Anger Management — "quick to anger"

In the margin I scribbled two words in pen.

PROCRASTINATION. INTERNAL DEADLINES.

I wrote them because I knew. I'd known for a while.

I'd gotten complacent.

I was 4th generation at Barriere Construction. The family company. I'd grown up riding jobs with my dad. I’d worked on crews since I was 15. I’d put in 80 hour weeks. I’d managed big jobs that made real money. I loved the work. I was supposed to be the future of the business. And I was busy proving I wasn't ready.

My VP didn't soft-pedal a single line. He sat me down. Read each item out loud. Set weekly check-ins. Told me exactly what needed to change and how he'd measure it.

It hurt.

Eight months later I was running the division. And I kept the paper on my wall as a reminder.

We're still close friends.

I partially owe my career to a one-page document and a boss who cared enough to make me read it.

Most managers I see today think they're being kind by holding back.

They're not. They're being cowards.

Saban wasn't nice. Wooden wasn't nice. Coach K wasn't nice. Care is the prerequisite. Truth is the proof.

The American workplace has spent fifteen years training that out of leaders. Performative empathy. Sandwich feedback. "Psychological safety" weaponized into never say anything hard. A whole generation of managers who literally cannot tell their best people what's wrong with their work.

That softness rots teams. The great ones can feel when feedback is being filtered. They lose respect. They leave. The mediocre stay - and stay mediocre.

Holding back the truth is the cheapest leadership.

Bill Walsh ran the 49ers on direct feedback. Andy Grove ran Intel on it. Toyota's Andon cord is direct feedback in physical form. High-performance organizations aren't built on kindness. They're built on the frictionless flow of accurate information. The manager who softens the signal is breaking the system.

Construction is one of the last industries where you can still talk like a human being to another human being. That's not a bug. That's an advantage.

So here's your assignment for Monday:

Pick the one person on your team you've been holding back on. Tell them the actual thing. Don't sandwich it. Don't pre-apologize. Tell them what's wrong, why it matters, and what you'll do together to fix it.

Watch what happens.

P.S. What's the hardest feedback you ever got? Hit reply.

In Case You Missed It:

Intelligent Bidding

Meaning to Call Isn’t A System

Taste The Soup

Enjoyed this newsletter? Forward it to a friend and have them sign up here!

About the Author

Tristan Wilson is the CEO and Founder of Edgevanta. We make AI agents for civil estimating. He is a 4th Generation Contractor, construction enthusiast, ultra runner, and bidding nerd. He worked his way up the ladder at Allan Myers in the Mid-Atlantic and his family’s former business Barriere Construction before starting Edgevanta in Nashville, where the company is based. Reach out to him at [email protected]